Garay, 28, is the face of the popular Instagram account @JayFromHouston, and some of her photos will have you doing a double-take. In one, Garay poses with her hair swept up in a bun, flawless makeup, and hoop earrings — a classic J.Lo look. In another total J.Lo moment, she cradles her chin in her hand, revealing perfectly manicured nails.
The bodybuilder is definitely aware that people think she looks like J.Lo. “So what you guys are telling me is that everybody has a twin and @jlo happens to be mine??? I’ll take it!” she wrote in one Instagram post, alongside a photo of herself and J.Lo … we think. It’s seriously hard to tell.
People are blown away by the doppelganger situation going on. “I swear I thought it was JLo when I saw your pic,” one person wrote in the comments. “I literally thought that was just two pics of J.Lo,” another said.
Of course, there’s one big difference between Lopez and Garay. While the pop star is known for being fit, Garay is a legitimate bodybuilder. She says she first got into bodybuilding about three years ago and fell in love with the sport. “I saw instant results and got addicted,” she says.
And that’s one more thing she and J.Lo have in common.