Support Us

We depend on donations to run this site. Please help us to keep public figures accountable by supporting the project.

Find out more

English-language site Site francophone

Africa Check
Skip to content

Home
Reports
Blog
How to fact-check
About us

Services
Donate

Get a weekly dose of facts
Published: 29th June 2017 (GMT) Last updated at 12:31
Subscribe to reports
Has Nigeria never allocated more than 30% of its budget to infrastructure projects?

Nigeria’s much delayed 2017 budget has been signed into law, but is it the first time spend on development projects has reached 30%, as has been reported? We checked.

Researched by David Ajikobi
Workers stand along a prototype railway line, to be constructed by China Railway Construction Corporation, at the launch of the construction of a railway between Lagos and Ibadan in March 2017. Photo: AFP/PIUS UTOMI EKPEI

Workers stand along a prototype railway line, to be constructed by China Railway Construction Corporation, at the launch of the construction of a railway between Lagos and Ibadan in March 2017. Photo: AFP/PIUS UTOMI EKPEI

Looking to spur an ailing economy, Nigeria’s acting president recently signed the 2017 budget into law, following months of delay.

The country last year experienced a contraction of its economy – the first in 25 years – due to low international oil prices, its main revenue earner.

“This budget is a budget of economic recovery and growth. It is designed to bring Nigeria out of recession,” acting president Yemi Osinbajo said after signing the record N7.44 trillion (US$23.6 billion) budget on 12 June.

Osinbajo, the vice president, is filling in for President Muhammadu Buhari, who has been on medical leave in the United Kingdom since 7 May 2017. The budget was passed by lawmakers in May, who increased it from the N7.3 trillion that Buhari had submitted in December 2016.

During the review, senate minority leader Godswill Akpabio was reported to have said that the 2017 budget represented the first time national spending on roads, power, railways and so forth would reach 30% of the total.
What is the current budget?

Through numerous phone calls and messages, Africa Check attempted to reach Akpabio to confirm that he made the reported remarks, but he did not respond.

The 2017 budget has N2.18 trillion set aside for spending on public projects, or about 29.3% of the total. (Note: This figure does not include N434.4 billion in special funding to statutory bodies such as the Niger Delta Development Commission.)

An economist at Lagos-based Vetiva Capital Management, Michael Famoroti, provided Africa Check with his analysis of government spending on development projects over the last 10 years.

The figures were sourced from the Budget Office of the Federation and news reports.

In the decade reviewed, Nigeria’s infrastructure budget has more than doubled: from N1.25 billion in 2008 to N2.18 trillion in 2017.

The 2015 budget signed by former president Goodluck Jonathan saw the lowest allocation to infrastructure projects in the period – at N556.9 billion, or 11% of the budget.

In at least 3 of those years – 2008, 2010 and 2013 – the allocation to capital projects has been more than 30% of the budget. The infrastructure share during this time was the highest in 2008, when it made up 37% of the total budget.

This is yet to happen in the first two years of Buhari’s administration. In the 2017 budget it is 29.3% while in 2016 it was 26.2%.

“Strictly speaking, capital expenditure allocation has surpassed 30% on a few occasions in the last decade based on available data,” Famoroti told Africa Check. “But actual cash-backed disbursement and [ministries, departments and agencies] utilisation has usually fallen short.”

Expenditure on projects is usually the first item to lose out if the budget faces challenges such as delays, inadequate funding and graft, the economist noted. His calculations shows that actual spending “barely tops 20% of budgeted spending for any year”.

“[The] key thing is implementation and monitoring. Given that capital expenditure is funded by borrowing, it is important that stakeholders scrutinise what the funds are used for,” said Famoroti.
Conclusion: Nigeria has allocated more than 30% of its budget on development projects before

During the drawn-out approval of Nigeria’s 2017 budget, a lawmaker said that it was the first time that allocations to development projects had surpassed 30% of the budget.

Senate minority leader Godswill Akpabio further urged less spending on recurrent expenses such as salaries so as to free up money to spend on power, railways and roads.

We looked at the last decade to see if the numbers stacked up. In at least 3 years of those, funding for development projects exceeded 30% of the total budget.

We therefore rate the minority leader’s claim as incorrect. That said, an analyst explained that implementation should be the main focus, as only a small proportion of budgeted capital expenditure funds actually reached the intended agencies.

Previous report 98% of South African Airways’ spending didn’t go to white-owned companies

Next report The Jubilee Party manifesto: 5 claims fact-checked

© Copyright Africa Check 2017. You may reproduce this report or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events, subject to providing a credit to “Africa Check a non-partisan organisation which promotes accuracy in public debate and the media. Twitter @AfricaCheck and www.africacheck.org”.
Fact or fiction?
We rate this claim as:
incorrect

Share exceeded in 2008, 2010 & 2013

How we rate claims
Share this report
Related reports
Nigerian women taking part in a Democracy Day parade in Owerri on 29 May 2017. Photo: AFP/MARCO LONGARI
Nigeria’s Democracy Day speech: Fact-checking sovereign savings, rice imports & infrastructure spend
11:15 | 14th June 2017
Passenger look out of the windows of a train at the Ebute-Metta headquarters of the Nigerian Railway Corporation in Lagos in March 7, 2017. Nigeria’s acting President Yemi Osinbajo has signed off on the construction of the Lagos-Ibadan double track railway line modernisation project to be done by the China Railway Construction Corporation (CRCC). The project, when completed, will open up direct transit from the coastal city of Lagos, Nigeria’s commercial capital, to Ibadan, in the heart of the south west. Photo: AFP/ Pius Utomi Ekpei
Has Nigeria not borrowed internationally since 2013? Minister misses mark
02:05 | 17th May 2017
Claim that Jonathan left Nigeria with 7 trillion naira deficit does not add up
08:23 | 4th August 2015
A man walks in the morning mist near wind turbines in the Ngong hills outside Nairobi, Kenya, in October 2010. Photo: AFP/TONY KARUMBA
Kenya’s budget speech: Do claims about power, investment & roads add up?
02:26 | 7th April 2017
Amos Sibanda watched cars in Camps Bay, Cape Town. Photo: MediaClubSouthAfrica.com
Democratic Alliance wrong to claim 67% of Cape Town’s budget spent on poor communities
07:15 | 14th July 2016
Donate to Africa Check

We depend on voluntary donations to run this site. Please help us to keep public figures accountable by supporting the project.

Find out more
We hold public figures accountable

ifcn-fact-checkers-code-of-principles-signatoryFor democracy to function, public figures need to be held to account for what they say. The claims they make need to be checked, openly and impartially. Africa Check is an independent, non-partisan organisation which assesses claims made in the public arena using journalistic skills and evidence drawn from the latest online tools, readers, public sources and experts, sorting fact from fiction and publishing the results.



Comments

comments